Spelling/Grammar Tools

Cmaier

Site Master
Staff Member
Site Donor
Posts
5,216
Reaction score
8,264
At my workplace, I use Microsoft Editor to check for any grammatical errors in my documents. It points out many things that I would've never noticed. I've also heard about Grammarly, but it's not something that I've personally used before.

I can;t use anything that sends what you type to their servers. I think grammarly does that? I may be wrong. I don;t know anything about Microsoft editor.
 

JayAgostino

Suspended
Posts
208
Reaction score
90
Location
Massachusetts
I can;t use anything that sends what you type to their servers. I think grammarly does that? I may be wrong. I don;t know anything about Microsoft editor.
Yeah, that's a fair point. I'd definitely trust Microsoft over Grammarly. The latter doesn't really have a major company behind it.
 

Cmaier

Site Master
Staff Member
Site Donor
Posts
5,216
Reaction score
8,264
Yeah, that's a fair point. I'd definitely trust Microsoft over Grammarly. The latter doesn't really have a major company behind it.
Even if I trusted grammarly I couldn’t use it if it works by sending the text to its servers. If you’ve got a trade secret, or you have an attorney work product document or an attorney-client privileged document, sharing it willingly with a third party can be a pretty good way to lose the right to call it a trade secret or to lose the legal privilege. There are similar issues with things like cloud storage or web-based email. You can sometimes solve the problem with iron clad contracts that require special precautions, etc., but in general it’s better to stick with self-hosted solutions and avoid the hassle.
 

Cmaier

Site Master
Staff Member
Site Donor
Posts
5,216
Reaction score
8,264
How are office suites like Google Workspace so successful then?

I don’t think they’re used much by anyone who has these issues (lawfirms, Hightech R&D companies, etc.). Google workspace is huge in education, and among people and organizations who don’t want to pay for Microsoft, but I think a lot its popularity has to do with price. Even medical professionals have to be careful - in order to be HIPAA compliant they need to sign a BAA. There are also data privacy issues with some of these services - if you type in someone’s name and address into a document in Germany, and that gets sent to a server in the U.S., are you violating european data privacy laws? I am not a European lawyer, so I don’t know the answer, but it’s something that I’d be careful about.
 

JayAgostino

Suspended
Posts
208
Reaction score
90
Location
Massachusetts
I don’t think they’re used much by anyone who has these issues (lawfirms, Hightech R&D companies, etc.). Google workspace is huge in education, and among people and organizations who don’t want to pay for Microsoft, but I think a lot its popularity has to do with price. Even medical professionals have to be careful - in order to be HIPAA compliant they need to sign a BAA. There are also data privacy issues with some of these services - if you type in someone’s name and address into a document in Germany, and that gets sent to a server in the U.S., are you violating european data privacy laws? I am not a European lawyer, so I don’t know the answer, but it’s something that I’d be careful about.
Home Depot and Costco appear to use Google Workspace.
 

Cmaier

Site Master
Staff Member
Site Donor
Posts
5,216
Reaction score
8,264
Home Depot and Costco appear to use Google Workspace.

Sure. I’m sure lots of big companies do. But neither Home Depot nor Costco falls into the categories I listed. To the extent they have R&D trade secrets or in-house legal departments, I’m sure those employees would avoid google workspace for anything that’s meant to be secret or privileged.
 

Cmaier

Site Master
Staff Member
Site Donor
Posts
5,216
Reaction score
8,264
Sure. I’m sure lots of big companies do. But neither Home Depot nor Costco falls into the categories I listed. To the extent they have R&D trade secrets or in-house legal departments, I’m sure those employees would avoid google workspace for anything that’s meant to be secret or privileged.
BTW, Costco also uses MS products, so I’m not sure what to make of these announcements.
 

JayAgostino

Suspended
Posts
208
Reaction score
90
Location
Massachusetts
I’m sure those employees would avoid google workspace for anything that’s meant to be secret or privileged.
Even Google (which obviously uses its own office suite)?
1658624001998.png
 

Cmaier

Site Master
Staff Member
Site Donor
Posts
5,216
Reaction score
8,264
Even Google (which obviously uses its own office suite)?
View attachment 16152

I think you’re confused. How would google be waiving attorney work product privilege by using its own servers? How would they render information not a trade secret by using their own servers?

You lose privilege if you intentionally share things with ANOTHER party (subject to various exceptions). You fail to take steps necessary to maintain trade secrets when you allow ANOTHER party to access them (subject to various exceptions).

Using your own service doesn’t cause these issues (assuming things are properly secured, etc. etc.)
 

Nycturne

Elite Member
Posts
1,111
Reaction score
1,426
Not to mention there is a big difference between using it for internal work vs legal requirements. And for some legal requirements, using a service like G Suite or Sharepoint can make some compliance easier than if you did it yourself.

But a lot of what Cmaier mentions is more strict than the sort of compliance things I’m thinking of.
 

Cmaier

Site Master
Staff Member
Site Donor
Posts
5,216
Reaction score
8,264
Not to mention there is a big difference between using it for internal work vs legal requirements. And for some legal requirements, using a service like G Suite or Sharepoint can make some compliance easier than if you did it yourself.

But a lot of what Cmaier mentions is more strict than the sort of compliance things I’m thinking of.
Yeah, for things like retention requirements, etc., these cloud services can be beneficial, in that they may be more easily achieved than if you try to do it yourself. But in a bunch of other situations the law doesn’t care about your convenience :)
 

Alli

Perfection
Staff Member
Site Donor
Posts
5,887
Reaction score
11,792
Location
Alabackwards
A lot of former classmates relied heavily on Grammerly to get through grad school. I’ve never tried it. MS drives me crazy with its underlining things that it feels need to be changed. Fortunately, my grasp on the English language, spelling, and grammar is pretty good.
 

Eric

Mama's lil stinker
Posts
11,294
Reaction score
21,744
Location
California
Instagram
Main Camera
Sony
A lot of former classmates relied heavily on Grammerly to get through grad school. I’ve never tried it. MS drives me crazy with its underlining things that it feels need to be changed. Fortunately, my grasp on the English language, spelling, and grammar is pretty good.
It has always frustrated me as well, if I want to use a comma where a semicolon should go I don't need some AI software package going all grammar nazi on me.
 

SuperMatt

Site Master
Posts
7,862
Reaction score
15,004
My grammar tool is the voice of my 5th-grade English teacher, Ms. Dallman. She never let anything slide. I recall some examples in particular. If one turned in a paper that confused “your” with “you’re” or “there” with “their“ or “they’re” she would return the paper and require it to be fixed before she would even grade it. I believe “too,” “to,” and “two” were part of this rule as well.

I still make mistakes anyway, but it has been a long time since the 5th grade.
 

Cmaier

Site Master
Staff Member
Site Donor
Posts
5,216
Reaction score
8,264
My grammar tool is the voice of my 5th-grade English teacher, Ms. Dallman. She never let anything slide. I recall some examples in particular. If one turned in a paper that confused “your” with “you’re” or “there” with “their“ or “they’re” she would return the paper and require it to be fixed before she would even grade it. I believe “too,” “to,” and “two” were part of this rule as well.

I still make mistakes anyway, but it has been a long time since the 5th grade.

We have an entire proofreading department. I rarely send them anything because what comes back is always a bunch of style suggestions that I reject. Nobody’s ever found a grammar error in my writing, at least. Once or twice there’s been a typo that spell-checking couldn’t catch.
 
Top Bottom
1 2